=====
From rich@brickbots.com:
Wow, that lighthouse is fantastic.  The modeling is great, you lit it well, and
the render came out just right.  It looks very realistic, but for some reason
it looks like a photograph of a miniature.  Sorry, I really just can't place
why.  In any case, the render is fantastic.  In any case, it is great and the
light is very well done.

Sadly the background does not quite mesh with the beautiful lighthouse.  If you
did not have time, or want to do a detailed background, maybe just obscuring
the jutty and coast with drifts of fog and blurring it all a bit might have
worked well to keep the illusion of reality.
=====
From hildurka@simnet.is:
Great fog. The textures look a bit flat. Why is the 
lighthouse in the foreground? I would have preferred to 
see the light coming towards you through the fog. I like 
the concept. 

=====
From dungbeatle@mail.tds.net:
Lighthouse looks a little too clean and perfect. Light seems to be coming from
wrong directions.
=====
From simon_smith@zen.co.uk:
It looks like a Lego lighthouse, in a Lego scene.

=====
From file:
nice composition and depth to the features of the lighthouse.  textures could be
rougher and more realistic.  water seems unnaturally like the caribbean.