=====
From reinhard.pieper@web.de:
The shadows on the earth and moon seem a bit odd to me. Maybe you could have
gone for a more dramatic composition.

=====
From aargri@gmail.com:
Nice texture on the Earth. You really get the impression of bumps, not just a
smooth sphere. The atmosphere is done really well too, but it looks like the
planet is being lit by two suns.
=====
From tek@evilsuperbrain.com:
The moon seems to just be a flat grey sphere, in such a simple image I'd expect
something more. Also the earth needs clouds.


=====
From RJohnson03@comcast.net:
The earth looks great!

=====
From marlo.steed@uleth.ca:
The concept sort of works.  The illumination on the dark side of the earth looks
a bit too much to me.  I also woud have gone for a more diffuse shadow on the
moon it is a bit too harsh.  The earth should have a slight glow around it to
simulate the atmosphere.

=====
From tomvw87@hotmail.com:
A bit simple, but a really cool texture for the earth-object.

=====
From file:
Earth looks perfect, lighting is great.
Notable for textures, originality, lighting


=====
From file:
cool