=====
From djhouy@paw.za.org:
I work with CAD myself, but personally hate it for rendering anything other than
technical stuff or houses, so I'm pretty impressed with what you have acheived
here. The coal, although well done, does not really make a solid connection
with the floor, and the camera set up bothers me, but all-in-all, well done.
=====
From irtc@tomandlu.co.uk:
A very nice image.

=====
From the_dark_allies@hotmail.com:

I like this image.  Though it could have done with some better shadowing?
=====
From gromit@ix.netcom.com:
the "spill" looks natural and dynamic (although a little coal dust might be
present?).  really like the floor texture.  The texture on the bench vertical
looks a little low-res