=====
From skipt1@aol.com:
3DSMAX?  At what point does this photograph turn into a rendering?  Please do
not falsify your descriptions and expect to receive any sort of score from it.

=====
From tek@evilsuperbrain.com:
Okay, that's a photo. And not even a very good one.


=====
From noe.falzon@tiscali.fr:
No explanations... Looks like a blend of photos to me...
=====
From AlaskaS@gmx.de:
Really good modeling and nice texturing! But some lines to creation and idea
would have been nice

=====
From emkaah@yahoo.com:
Very photorealistic. But then, it is a photo.

=====
From rgow@lanset.com:
This looks like a rules violation to me. What is 3d?  I see a photoshop
composite.

=====
From g.ficara@oltrelinux.com:

IMHO, without the moon this image could pass as a photo-shot... Great realism!

=====
From hawatino2010@yahoo.com:

very realistic
=====
From i-mcnamara@cornellcollege.edu:
Awesome work on this one.  The sky is amazing, the moon is a great touch, and
the cliff dwellings are amazingly modeled.  Great work, keep sending in the
entries for us to gawk over.


=====
From enrique.sahagun@uam.es:
I have been looking at your image for a long time trying to find something wrong
but it is very difficult. Finally I have find something which it is not very
important. In my opinion the moon (and its light) is not well connected with
the rest of the image.

=====
From klynn@telefish.net:
I need more information about how the image was created!

=====
From jacoons@ameritech.net:
This image is realistic, but appear *TOO* realistic to be a real image. That
either means it really *IS* excellent or has been fabricated. I choose to
believe that it is realistic and give you the benefit of the doubt. 

=====
From ericf@foothill.net:
First I looked at the time for  your render, looked the size of the image that
was loading, and wondered why such a long render for a small image.  When it
finished loading I understood.  Very nice image, feels very real.  The sky
texture is especially nice.
=====
From raytracing@grayproductions.net:
Raytrace that and I'll really be impressed.
=====
From darwallace@earthlink.net:
The moon is too bright given the time of day.


=====
From file:
Hum
Notable for lighting, modelling


=====
From file:
This one of the most photo-realistic images of the round. Would be interested to
know how you did it.


=====
From file:
This is really good. I wish you had said more about its creation.