=====
From skipt1@aol.com:
This scene came out quite well.  I like the dunes, and the rocks, and the
textures accent them well.  It seems a bit simple though.
=====
From tek@evilsuperbrain.com:
Very nice image. Just one criticism: the lighting on the moon doesn't match the
lighting in the foreground. This is a pretty common error but it always annoys
me.





=====
From rgow@lanset.com:
Great image! Very nice dunes! Nice clouds & moon too. Can't really find any
defects in this one. Nitpick; texture on stone columns is slightly shiny,
almost looks wet.



=====
From i-mcnamara@cornellcollege.edu:
Your humble try turned out quite well.  The sand looks great, as does the sky,
and the rocks are quite good as well, though their scale seems a bit off. 
Excellent work here.
=====
From jacoons@ameritech.net:
Good concept, with well-done clouds and moon shot. The dunes are quite good, but
something about the "rocks" lack realism, perhaps the amount of reflection. I
think adding a "rough normal" would improve the rocks and possible the sand. 
=====
From ericf@foothill.net:
Nice sand and dunes, the rock shapes are good, but don't seem to fit well,
possibly because of their color.  Good sky, the moon image is a nice touch.

=====
From boork@zipcon.net:
I love the rocks - both the shape and the texture.


=====
From raytracing@grayproductions.net:
Love that moon!
=====
From darwallace@earthlink.net:
Some smaller stones and gravel around the mesas would have helped.


=====
From file:
Need work
Notable for lighting


=====
From file:
Nice dunes. The pillars are well modeled, but need a little more texture
tweaking.