=====
From jonathas@ifi.uio.no:
I really like the board here - the bevelling goes a long way to making it more
realistic, IHMO. I think the single spotlight gives the image an outdoors feel,
maybe radiosity and/or multiple spotlights and deep shadows would give more of
a war-room intensity? Great image! 



=====
From higginsdj@bigpond.com:
Nice but too cluttered - no centre of interest

=====
From james@imperiumglobal.com:
try to work on your lighting some more to give it some atmosphere.  quite
original.
=====
From philip.chan@home.com:
You did a pretty good job with the texturing for the marble countries and the
water.  I would have liked to see more detail in the models of the pieces,
particularily the battleships and the aircraft carrier.

=====
From dan@sypher7.com:
Creative and pleasing to look at. Very well done.
=====
From lrwii@joplin.com:
The planes don't show up well against the marble. 
Looking at you scene for awhile produces eye strain.

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
I don't think Europe looks realistic here, but who 
cares... it looks great (and more artistic than Europe 
normally looks, I think.)  Nice scene overall, and a good 
interpretation of the topic.

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
Good work.  I like the all-encompassing wide-angle camera viewpoint.  Not 
having played (or even seen) A&A, I cannot comment on the realism of the 
image.  Good technique to create the countries.

=====
From tm-ray@consistent.org:
I like the concept, and the modelling of the pieces looks good.  The
metal texture looks slightly off, although I can't explain how
exactly.  Shame about having to use stone textures off the 'net, but
they did come out well.

=====
From delfeld@mailcity.com:
I played Axis an Allies in college for a while, but one of my roommates was on a
quest to find out if there were a way to win if you started out with Japan.  He
spent a whole semester staying up until 2:00 am trying to figure it out.  

Anyway, the water is a little off-setting. . . more reflection would help.  The
picture is hard to understand visually.  There are too many non-essential
areas, such as the marbling and beveling of the countries.  Pulling the camera
out a bit might solve the crowded feel of it.  


=====
From r@client121041.atl.attbroadband.com:
Notable for modelling, textures