=====
From charliemc@prodigy.net:

Good.
=====
From hgregory3@aol.com:
Artistic - Nicely done "Earth Rise"
Concept - A contrast it is.

=====
From steve@neurotrain.com:
A 10 T 10 C 15
This shot has been done so many times that you needed 
to add something really special to make it stand 
out...perhaps an earthrise over the crest of the moon 
viewed from the dark side of the moon.

Techincally there are three things in the picture - the 
sky, the moon and the earth.  On the moon the stars do 
not "twinkle" because there is no amosphere to defract 
the light...  Textures really need to be worked on...
Good Concept.

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
Good realism on the Earth.  The moon, however, still looks like an image map
on a sphere.
I think the stars are a little too big, too many pixels each.  As a point
source, they should hardly be more than one pixel.

=====
From hfventer@ing.sun.ac.za:
Great view :)  A slightly less bent horizon would have 
brought the barren moon closer to the viewer...