=====
From mar@physics.usyd.edu.au:
Interesting idea, and the photo reflection is a good bit of technical trickery,
but I think it gets lost amongst the lamp and other objects.

=====
From hgregory3@aol.com:
Technical - Impressed with the picture reflection. (is that a print out of a
POV file on the desk?) Nice drinking glass (very realistic).
Concept - There is a contrast of sorts.

=====
From steve@neurotrain.com:
A 17 T 12 C 20
Excellent concept (that's why you get the 20)
I upped the tech score when I realized how you did it.  I 
thought you had rendered the image with the "old" photo 
and simply used the reflection as a texture.  However, 
there needs to be more detail in the background (the wall 
is a solid piece of wood - next time make 15 or 20 
"planks") and the table (make it looked less than brand 
new)
The crossstitch is nice, but very plain - my sister does 
this as a hobby and they are always a least three colours 
and have patterns on the border
Finally, the artistic score is not perfect because I think it 
would have been way more cool if you had reflected an 
old lamp and a different cross stitch as well.

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
Some good work here.  The shape of the lamp is 
interesting. I like the sampler.  The glass looks nice too, 
with the light shining through it.

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
Good "cross stitch" effect.

=====
From hfventer@ing.sun.ac.za:
Maybe its just me, but I didnt notice the reflected 
immage till I read the description.  Its not central enough 
to the immage to make it stand out.  
Once you notice it, its quite good tho :)