=====
From luisvaloyes@malditasea.zzn.com:
nice job...

=====
From elvish_archer@mailcity.com:
it's just like an abandoned lab with a fresh apple

=====
From Stickgod01@aol.com:
Awesome! It looks so real, so thought out! Great modelling on everything, I
especially like the way the blue flame reacts with the beaker.



=====
From stephenhasmail@yahoo.com:
It is very hard with 3D graphics to create images that look organic, old, and/or
dirty, but I think you have succeeded quite well.  I'm glad there were two of
you working on this, because it would have taken one person more than two
months.

=====
From tji@euskalnet.net:
The best image in my opinion, I hope you win.
Incredible work with the textures, specially the flame
and the jar with the tea bag, and very good models.


=====
From bourzeix@francenet.fr:
Hum, I would not like to be obliged to clean to whole 
place !! ;-)
And I'm not sure I'd want some tea either ...

=====
From marlo.steed@home.com:

Some of textures needed a bit more realism but overall good effort.
=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
A lot of detailed clutter in this scene.  All the glass 
objects look good, and I like the stained periodic table.  
The telephone looks like it should have overbalanced 
and fallen off the table the way it's positioned, though.  
Nice shaping on the chairs, and on the apple (although 
the edges of the bite mark look a bit regular to me).

=====
From jaime@ctav.es:
Damn! This union is great! I can see how well you complemented each other,
giving us the best dirty raytrace ever seen. Modelling techniques are blended
with mastery. I've some curiosity about the texturing techniques, as they 
must have been done in pov, but they resemble like typical 3ds texturing 
style. Perhaps you even exported textures? And how? They are really amazing! 

And, only to acomplish my obligation to criticize, I must notice that light 
placement is perhaps the weak point of the scene. The light in front of the 
foreground objects is a bit too aligned with the camera, resulting in a lack
of visible shadows, like a commercial presentation. I would prefered simply 
another ceil light, a bit behind the camera. But well , that's IMHO...

=====
From whitey@telefragged.com:
i like it

=====
From mar@physics.usyd.edu.au:
This is an exceptional image... the detail in the modelling and texturing is
astounding. Nice composition, and it tells a story too. The little details
are great - the bent paperclip, the marker with no lid, the Coke cans in the
cupboard, and most of all the *dirt*.. everywhere! If this doesn't win a
prize this round it will be an injustice. A successful collaboration, well
done.

=====
From albiaprime@aol.com:
Artistic: WOW! Lots of detail and things to look for (and looks similar to the
lab my wife works in) namely cluttered up.
Technical: Excellent work
Theme: Full Marks!  Very impressive interpretation.


=====
From file:
Notable for composition, modelling, textures